Pvon
I agree. There is definitely some conflict between the 2. There is no reason to try and "one up" another just because books have been written by them. Also, there is a language barrier with Mr. Scapini that I think comes across as being brash and holier than thou attitude.
Now for the rings. I like the history! I don't (or didn't) collect for the political aspect of the items. Don't and never did support 3rd Reich policy. If you collect for the history and personality of the recipients, it is fun. Not sure if that makes sense but just saying if you want to delve into the metallurgy that is fine, just don't think everyone will follow your step:)