It seems that yes, it is for real.
I think that John has hit the nail on the head and that a couple or perhaps more have a bad case of auction fever. I think the dagger is in nice condition and is either polished up or in factory new condition.
I think Craig knows the difference!
I would have had a stab at this were it not for two things.
Number one I agree with Kevin and do not like that pommel on an SMF.
Secondly, the price went well above any realistic valuation on day 2.
Great news for the consignor who is the real winner here.