UBB.threads Forums Edged Weapons SA & NSKK Dagger Forum SA collectors, need your help

Well the Final McSARR is finished, but some questions remain. In the past I had accepted some suggestions from others as to the validity of some questionable makers. However significant time has passed and we have not been able to verify some. Indeed is has now been 7 years since a previously unrecognized maker has emerged. So for the Final McSARR I have only included makers that have been personally verified by Dave Hohaus or myself. I am asking the collecting body if anyone can verify the following makers as having definitely produced Early SA daggers(no RZMs). If you own or have good photos of any of the following makers, please post them or mail them too me at nmcalvanah@centurytel.net Anyone who can provide one will get a free Final McSARR.
Most likely to exist
J SCHMIDT & SOHNE(bull head with knives beneath)
GEBR WEYERSBERG (trumpet)
BRUNO HEIMBUCHER
GOTTLIEB HAMMESFAHR(pyramid) beware, many fakes
RICH HERDER(diamond)
ALCOSA again many fakes
ROBERT KLASS (storks)
ARTHUR EVERTZ (name in arch)
Less likely to exist
ERNST GERLING (running man)
HACK (fish)
CARL HALBACH (water tower)
HERDER & CO (eagle ALDERBLICK)
BERTRAM C REINHARD (2 chickens)
PILS &SOHN (anvil)
PUMETO
ROBERT MIDDLEDORF (ROMI)
ROBERT MULLER (crown and wreath)
KARL OSCHMANN
ERNST MANDEWIRTH (HACCOMPA)
GUSTAV VOLKER
Thanks, any questions please call or email- Mike McAlvanah

Mike have you got Peter Lungstrass as shown by Colonels Closet in a NSKK thread just down the page a little?
Reason I ask is they are not in the revision of Fisher that I have

Yes, Peter Lungstrass is fine and is on McSARR-Mike

Mike, When will the list be available?

At SOS-March 4- then by mail afterwards-Mike

Mike what will the price be by mail?.....Regards Scott.

Scotland will be $16 or one bottle of scotch.Mike

quote:

Originally posted by Mike McAlvanah:
Scotland will be $16 or one bottle of scotch.Mike

Mike sounds like a done deal 1 bottle of Famous Grouse Scotch Whiskey on its way to the USA .....Cheers Scott.

At 16 bucks/bottle it wont be very good!!!
Seiler ( Yank in uk)

Hey, for a bottle of scotch, I'll send him 2 McSARRs! Mike

Hi Mike this Klass dagger was on ebay 2 years ago,I sent the photos to Dave ,he thought that maybe someone had ground the RZM mark of.Sorry the photo is not very good,nats

Wow, cant tell very much from that pic- anyone else have a pic? Mike

quote:

HERDER & CO (eagle ALDERBLICK)

Mike,
Correct spelling is ADLERBLICK ("eagle view"; eagle in German is ADLER)

Thanks Ingo-Mike

Nats,

there are three Klass marks known:

1. The SS Rohm mark which is small and close to the crossguard. I cannot find an image right now, but is is smaller than the one you show.

2. The regular SS Klass mark. It is larger than the one you show. See below

3. The SA transitional trademark. Same size and placement as the one you show. I have seen two blades that looked as they had been reworked to remove the letters & numbers but leave the trademark.

Dave

Do old photo's of your new Alcosa count?

If you are going to the SOS and have news on any of the makers that Mike has posted, please find him and let him know.

Dave