I bought a brother for my NSDAP ring and would like to hear some opinions on it.

Looks exectly like my NSDAP ring, is marked 835 and the enamel is perfect.

Kris.

pic2

pic3

pic4

Super find! One great looking pair of enamel rings, Kris. Can you give us some idea how you found them?

Kris,

Nice find and thanks for showing them.

Kris, your rings are beautiful and in the best condition.Congrats!
Cheers,
Benten

Man, I'd REALLY like an SA ring like that...

IMHO - COPY 100%

Stamp says it all for me....

Wow, almost 10 years ago since I bought this SA ring.
Has been in my reprobox for a long time now.

Still like the party ring.

Kris.

I like the party ring too

Hi Evgeniy, don't get me wrong -I'm not arguing with your expert knowledge, but would you care to elaborate on how/why it is fake? I wouldn't have noticed, still trying to learn here... is it the stamp, or...?
Mark

That SA is a early G.I. reproduction.. It has faults on the outside as well as inside. Also the poorly unfinished inner band. E. might have his own reasons too.
Those of us here in the US see this ring at the bigger shows SOS, MAX etc. every year!

Some time I show here original SA ring, with broken band.
Symbol of SA was made more qulity then in fist shot.
Because I think it 100% copy ...

Looking forward to it, real SA's are like hens teeth.....number 2 on my want list right now! Impossible to find an authentic one!!

Hi guys and what about this one ??

hi members
just looking over all these rings including the party ring i dont like any of them in my opinion they are all fakes aged to look old in all the years collecting these third reich rings i have never seen any so called party rings and these so called s/a rings please look at all these rings and please look carefully to the ring itself not the party enameling or the s/a enameling the mountings are all the same no they are not period made rings come on guys put up some period made rings leave the newly made crap behind im sorry if i hurt any bodys feelings this is my honest opinion best andy militarynut

No problem Andy.
Sometimes opinions diverge

And i like mine and Gottliebs too.

Here still an other

Wow interesting thread! I wonder what Hapur might have to say abut this...

Wow odal, your second one looks aces! Beautiful ring, I like what I see!! From your collection?

hi members
chris i would like to ask you this question as i think your picture is kind of dark front on your s/a ring is that black enameling that i see or dark red cant really tell . second question it appears to be the same mounting as odels s/a ring only difference i see is the very lite etching on the 835 silver content mark compared to odels mark which is pressed in to the silver mount not etched yours is etched not stamped while the metal is in the makeing i feel odels s/a ring is correct pressed markings . most of these rings that are appearing on the net has darkned back ground on the mounting my honest opinion i like odels markings better i feel more secure with his s/a ring . odel thank you very much for posting your nice s/a ring i like it very much but still in my honest opinion i certainly dont like any of the above outher rings sorry but this is still my honest opinion thanks andy militarynut

like Odals,,, even liking Gottliebs.. any hallmarks or content?

yeah, like a black enamel SS ring a SA is another real hard one to find. The G.I. copies now with 20 so years of age are dangerous. I see plenty at the big shows and the owners just can't believe they are fake..

Yes, i still have it for years. Exact the same pattern as my black enamel SS one

I'd say repro, faults inside and outside.

Which one Rich?

First one, not yours

Thanks Rich!