UBB.threads
Posted By: Stirnpanzer Railway 2nd model - Original ? - 05/20/2021 07:47 PM
Hi,

I have this on approval, but have a few concerns.

The pommel i dont think is aluminium, but another base metal zinc possibly, and the ring below the thinnner wide ring seems bigger than others i've observed.
The crossguard is 81mm wide, at appears to be the same metal as the pommel.
The scabbard is magnetic and a nickle type plating, (not brished) also the casting marks on the grip.

Red Flags ?

Thanks

Attached picture Rail_1 (Medium).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_2 (Medium).JPEG
Posted By: Stirnpanzer Re: Railway 2nd model - Original ? - 05/20/2021 07:48 PM
more pics

Attached picture Rail_3 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_4 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_5 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_6 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_7 (Custom).JPEG
Posted By: Stirnpanzer Re: Railway 2nd model - Original ? - 05/20/2021 07:56 PM
more pics

Attached picture Rail_8 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_9 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_10 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_11 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_12 (Custom).JPEG
Posted By: Stirnpanzer Re: Railway 2nd model - Original ? - 05/20/2021 07:57 PM
more pics

Attached picture Rail_13 (Custom).JPEG
Attached picture Rail_14 (Custom).JPEG
Posted By: Dave Re: Railway 2nd model - Original ? - 05/20/2021 09:39 PM
As you know, my specialty is SA/SS, but to me lots of things look just a little off.

The grip leans a little and so does the pommel ... the crossguard detail does not seem right ... and the lower scabbard detail (above) is slightly different on the left vs right.

Dave
Posted By: Stirnpanzer Re: Railway 2nd model - Original ? - 05/21/2021 05:32 PM
Yes it is bad...

Found this old post...very helpful

Thanks

https://forum.germandaggers.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=261343#
Posted By: Billy G. Re: Railway 2nd model - Original ? - 05/24/2021 11:33 AM
This thread is a good reminder of the quality of Bahnschutz reproductions out there. Things on the modern pieces may be just a little off but they can fool plenty of guys.
© Your new forums