UBB.threads
Posted By: chrissutter ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:11 AM
Because of it's under the inner liner cliped an not stiched RZM tag, this visor may be worth to be exposed in this forum. Any opinion about this unusual Erel made visor would be welcome.
thank you in advance.
Christian

Attached picture VISOR1.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:12 AM
2

Attached picture VISOR2.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:13 AM
3

Attached picture VISOR3.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:13 AM
4

Attached picture VISOR4.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:14 AM
5

Attached picture VISOR5.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:14 AM
6

Attached picture VISOR6.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:15 AM
7

Attached picture VISOR7.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:15 AM
8

Attached picture VISOR8.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:16 AM
9

Attached picture VISOR9.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:17 AM
10

Attached picture VISOR10.JPG
Posted By: militarymania Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 04:35 AM
it appears to have all the right componets that a good hat should have,,,no red flags to me,,,
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 05:03 AM
Hy Bob,
thank you for this first answer !
Here the final set of pictures

Attached picture VISOR11.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 05:04 AM
12

Attached picture VISOR12.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 05:04 AM
13

Attached picture VISOR13.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 05:05 AM
and final one !!

Attached picture VISOR14.JPG
Posted By: Bob Coleman Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 03:17 PM
FOR ME, THIS IS A POORLY MADE FAKE. THE CROWN PIPING IS ACTUALLY IN THE SIDE OF THE CAP, THE SEWN JOINTS ARE OOORLY DONE. THE RZM TAG IS POSITIONED INCORRECTLY AND THE INSIGNIA APPEAR TO BE FAKE. THE SHAPE IS POOR AND HAS NOT ANY RESEMBLENCE TO THE WORK FOUND IN AN EREL VISOR CAP.
Posted By: Josias Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 05:23 PM
Isn't there usually a sponge-like padding material behind the sweatband at the forehead area? The visor part looks original. A Frankenstein?
Posted By: PASCAL B. Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 05:52 PM
The tag could be OK...
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 07:57 PM
Pascal may be right,
I did find somewhere in this forum, some times ago, another Erel RZM tag supposed to be from an original visor;
The comparison of this one with the one of my visor may be of interest I think.

Attached picture HG-45l.jpg
Posted By: Bob Coleman Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/02/2009 10:45 PM
quote:
Originally posted by Bob Coleman:
FOR ME, THIS IS A POORLY MADE FAKE. THE CROWN PIPING IS ACTUALLY IN THE SIDE OF THE CAP, THE SEWN JOINTS ARE POORLY DONE. THE RZM TAG IS POSITIONED INCORRECTLY AND THE INSIGNIA APPEAR TO BE FAKE. THE SHAPE IS POOR AND HAS NOT ANY RESEMBLENCE TO THE WORK FOUND IN AN EREL VISOR CAP.
Posted By: stonemint Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/03/2009 01:40 AM
I concur with Bob--it is a Frankenstein cap.
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/03/2009 07:01 AM
Thank you Bob and Stonemind for your opinions on this item.
Howewer, if a "Frankenstein Cap" means a put togheter, I don't share at all this appreciation because it doesn't resist to a direct examination.
There is indeed no such evidence that the cap could have been made from different separate parts.
I think also Bob's opinion about the position of the crown piping interesting but also in this case It may not determine the fact that it's not an original Erel made.
Please see the position of another crown piping, from an earlier Erel made NCO visor, from the enclosed pictures.
It's true that the above shown cap has no stiffener in it's piping, but this is not uncommun neither.

Attached picture erel1.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/03/2009 07:03 AM
second

Attached picture erel2.JPG
Posted By: chrissutter Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/03/2009 07:04 AM
and the tag, with the same "81" stamp as at the other tags...

Attached picture erel3.JPG
Posted By: stonemint Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/05/2009 05:39 AM
Maybe this will help. This is a true Erel private-purchase (non-RZM) A-SS visor for comparison:

Attached picture privpurch.jpg
Posted By: S.Vestae Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/05/2009 10:44 AM
I am agree with Bob, this is a fake cap with good insignia

Sebastien.
Posted By: Josias Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/06/2009 06:30 PM
A big red flag is the piping, which is is WAY too fuzzy. Original piping doesn't fray this badly. Compare to this early, very worn cap. Despite the overall wear, notice almost NO fraying.

Attached picture Copy_of_MVC-581F.JPG
Posted By: Josias Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/06/2009 06:31 PM
Crown piping..

Attached picture MVC-580F.JPG
Posted By: Josias Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/06/2009 06:40 PM
One last factor - Notice how the bottom edge of the cap in this next pic tilts UPWARD from the visor toward the back. Unless the cap was stored sideways or upside down, this feature is present on many caps from sitting on a shelf for many years. This is a feature I like to see, although it's absence doesn't prove it's fake. However, I've NEVER seen this feature on a fake cap!!

Attached picture MVC-584F.JPG
Posted By: violin Re: ALGEMEINE OFFICER EREL VISOR - 04/07/2009 01:41 AM
Looks like there is a ghost shadow of an older skull left of the current one. I certainly don't think these are original to the cap and the patina is too new for the rest of the cap and the shape is not Erel. Just my thoughts. David
© Your new forums