UBB.threads
Posted By: JamesT SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/23/2011 09:36 AM
Gentlemen

I know these are rarer than hens teeth so have every expectation that this is a fake but what do you folks think?

Many thanks

james

Attached picture 01.jpg
Attached picture 02.jpg
Attached picture 03.jpg
Attached picture 04.jpg
Posted By: JamesT Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/23/2011 09:38 AM
I'm trying to get bigger pics

Attached picture P1230326 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230330 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230331 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230332 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230333 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230334 [1600x1200].JPG
Posted By: wotan Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/23/2011 10:58 AM
The pics are not bad but the true overall color of the dagger, which is an important feature, imo does not come to light.
This said I did look for special features which an original FHH has to have and I have to say that I miss them...
Also the grip does not have the right shape and surface (which is extremely hard to dublicate/fake).
Although naturally an in hand inspection would be necessary I personally would tend (for 95%) to think it�s a fake dagger.
Regards,
Posted By: wotan Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/23/2011 11:01 AM
Can you additionally show detailed pics from the scabbard bands (from all sides) and from the pebbling of the scabbard near the tip of the scabbard, both sides?
Regards,
Posted By: JamesT Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/23/2011 01:48 PM
Thanks Wotan. I will try to get more pictures

many thanks

James
Posted By: JamesT Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/23/2011 10:27 PM
Here are some more pics

Do these help?

Many thanks

Attached picture P1230343 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230344 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230346 [1600x1200].JPG
Attached picture P1230354 [1600x1200].JPG
Posted By: wotan Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 08:38 AM
Hello,
now 99,9% a fake.
Regards,
Posted By: wotan Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 08:46 AM
Here you have an original one. sorry, since the new GD.C I am not able to manage load a larger looking pic.
Regards,

Attached picture 01a.jpg
Posted By: JohnZ Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 03:09 PM
Sorry for the relatively poor pics, but here is another.

John

Attached picture Obverse.JPG
Attached picture Reverse.JPG
Attached picture Obverse Grip.JPG
Attached picture Reverse Grip.JPG
Attached picture TM 2.JPG
Posted By: lakesidetrader Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 03:24 PM
Wow John, very impressive!! grin
Few people realize how very rare these things are.
Posted By: Heavy D Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 03:25 PM
Wow thats some awesome militaria! One day Ill find one.....sorry its not the real thing J....but A for effort type of thing.
Posted By: JamesT Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 06:26 PM
Beautiful dagger. I'm sure I saw somewhere that they are all numbered. Is this correct.

And thanks for your help on my original question

All the best

James
Posted By: JohnZ Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 08:01 PM
Mine is numbered 31.

So, I have been told..I will not try to disassemble this one.

John
Posted By: Larry C Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/24/2011 11:56 PM
John whats the name i see etched on the back of the cross guard and BTW John and Wotan,, very impressive! Something of this calibre Im surprised that the owner would scratch his name on the back of the guard instead of getting it etched,, still very nice!! best Larry
Posted By: lakesidetrader Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/25/2011 01:11 AM
Also I'm wondering what was the requirement to be allowed to own one of these?
Posted By: zorro Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/25/2011 02:21 AM
Don't be too hard own yourself.Even the reproductions bring good money these days.
Posted By: Ronald Weinand Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/25/2011 08:50 AM
Is there a name on the crossguard John?
Posted By: wotan Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/25/2011 09:30 AM
@lakesidetrader: I have not seen any written period regulation but to my best knowledge these daggers (which were duty-daggers!!! not honor daggers; beside these few different honor daggers were awarded) were worn by all leaders of the Standarte FHH and the leaders of the staff of OSAF (highest SA leadership).
Regards,
Posted By: JohnZ Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/25/2011 03:13 PM
The name inscribed Brauneck, Ron and Siegfried.

John

Attached picture Reverse Crosguard Name.JPG
Posted By: wotan Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/25/2011 05:35 PM
Obviously Hermann Brauneck, dob 19.12.1894, Leader of the Sanit�tshauptamt within the OSAF. Highest grade SA-Obergruppenf�hrer. He died 27.7.1942 at Kertsch (KIA?) and has his grave at the warriers cemetary at Sewastopol-Gontscharnoje.
Regards,
Posted By: Heavy D Re: SA Feldherrnhalle - 06/30/2011 04:14 PM
Wow......the hunt is on.....
© Your new forums