UBB.threads
Posted By: janhuvaj new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 09:25 AM
Hello everyone. I am a new member in this forum. I need a advise and opinions on SA daggers, I always fasinated by their desing and look and i always wanted to have one but unfortunately i have very little knowledge and limited sources. There is some examples i am thinking to get which prices goes from 1000 usd to 1500 usd( tprices are like that where i live unfortunately) but i have no idea which maker is better option for that price scale. Or a person who only planing to get only one it doesnt metter much as a condition of dagger?

I believe none of those are rare manufactorer but maybe the quality of some are better than the others? :
Arthur Schuttelhofer & Co. (thats most expensive)
Dick,Paul F.
RZM M7/42 WKC Solingen,
RZM M7/85 - Arthur Evertz, Solingen.
RZM M7/10/1941 J.A Henkels, Zwillingswerk, Solingen

also some are in better shape and some has hanger.

I should ask like " what i must look more importantly before buying a dagger"

thank you in advance!

Attached picture 280925554.0.jpg
Posted By: janhuvaj Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 09:34 AM
[img]https://b.itemimg.com/i/288401448.0.jpg?1[/img]

[img]https://b.itemimg.com/i/285956444.0.jpg?1[/img]

[Linked Image from b.itemimg.com]

[img]https://b.itemimg.com/i/265196378.1.jpg?2[/img]

[img]https://b.itemimg.com/i/280925835.0.jpg?1[/img]

those are the examples i am considering (photo of a arthur&co on top)
Posted By: Dave Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 03:20 PM
Hello, Jan !

Welcome to GDC. If you look back to old posts in this forum you will find much information.

To answer your question, look for:

- Less wear, and even balanced wear

- NO signs of repairs

- No signs of high polishing

- Good fit between dagger and scabbard

- Earlier daggers with the maker's mark, like F. Dick. They are better quality than RZM daggers.

Also, please post all photos, not just the links.

Dave
Posted By: janhuvaj Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 03:35 PM
Hello. Thank you for answer! Sorry I just uploaded them as photo links but it didn’t show all . Those are most expensive ones I am looking. This one is F.Dick

Attached picture E28ED58A-4710-472E-9BBC-7EFA2E7AD21D.jpeg
Posted By: janhuvaj Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 03:42 PM
this one is Arthur Schuttelhofer. They from different sellers but both are in same price. But one has hanger and this one seems to be in better condition

Attached picture 580B1C1D-F3D9-4E5E-8805-C1E55B3247FE.jpeg
Attached picture 6A8008F9-394A-40F6-9B57-5D40A9AE4BA8.jpeg
Posted By: janhuvaj Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 03:48 PM
This one is WKC Solingen a Little bit cheaper but seems to in good condition with hanger. If it is original condition

Attached picture D96C9905-DCED-4D66-9E1D-38C8C172A8D6.jpeg
Posted By: janhuvaj Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 03:58 PM
Arthur Evertz, Solingen. This one only little bit cheaper from last one.

Attached picture ED485903-F16E-485A-BAB5-D57DBDE08C32.jpeg
Posted By: janhuvaj Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 04:06 PM
RZM M7/10/1941 J.A Henkels, Zwillingswerk, Solingen. Although even I liked this one in first look (also 350 dollar price difference with the first one) I noticed there is something like stain on blade. I believe that’s all. There is also some other cheaper variants but not so good by condition

Attached picture 0D99D3E3-ACEC-474C-AA47-605E75DC6F07.jpeg
Posted By: Dave Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 06:28 PM
If I was buying,

1. Schutelhoffer

2. F. Dick. (The metal buckle and clip for the hanger are OK, but leather is too long)

Dave
Posted By: janhuvaj Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/07/2023 06:56 PM
Thank you for suggesting!
Posted By: Dave Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 06/10/2023 09:37 PM
Did you buy it , Jan ?
Posted By: Seppi Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 01/14/2024 10:39 AM
Hello all ,

I submit you this dagger and more than the authenticity of the blade it's the letter *W* allocated to the FHH which creates a doubt :

[Linked Image from imagizer.imageshack.com]

Is somebody can show a dagger with such a *W* ? thanks to him .

Your opinon will be helpfull and I thank you in advance , best from JL+
Posted By: Seppi Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 01/14/2024 11:07 AM
Addition ,

Here a zoom of the letter :[img]http://

[Linked Image from imagizer.imageshack.com]
[/img]

Good luck = S+
Posted By: Dave Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 01/14/2024 01:11 PM
Looks from what I see, Seppi.

A very hard to find Krieger.

Can we see the rest of it ?
Posted By: Seppi Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 01/14/2024 03:02 PM
Dave , sorry but the dagger is now sold and no more pics are available ,.. I agree , it's stupid to sale a Krieger !

Bye and thanks = JL+
That is indeed a special "W" gau stamp!, with the wide top ends.
Posted By: Seppi Re: new member asking advise for SA dagger - 01/14/2024 04:53 PM
Thanks Hermann , a nice dagger unfortunately sold ...

S+
© Your new forums