Sorry but for me the 2nd set of photos are worse. Where you have Pat and I convinced it's 2 gorgets...you got to either get someone to take better clearer photos in natural light where details can be made out, or another camera with a macro setting.
Snap close ups of the Lip around the chain end, the button tang, gorget lip, full close up of figure. Describe what kind of cloth it is. We see only black. How is it attached, if you can see? Is the chain nickel plated? Is the Gorget body Nickel plated? All these naratives with clear detailed photos will help with a proper determination.
Snap a lot of photos and pick out the best you can find and then post. Remember we haven't seen it. Unless better photos are forthcoming I can't help you further perhaps others may.

-serge-